- A short comparison about the best products we found on the market
- Proxxon 28092: the best coping saw?
- BLACK+DECKER BDEJS600C Smart Select Jig Saw: the best quality/price ratio of the moment
- Tack Life a cheap but reliable scroll saw
- Band saw or scroll saw?
- How to choose a scroll saw?
For perfect curve shapes, there’s nothing like a scroll saw. Whether you are an individual or a professional, you still have to choose the right model! This buying guide is here to help you make the right choice among the best singing saws of the moment according to your budget!
A short comparison about the best products we found on the market
Here are the top 3 models we will talk about:
- Proxxon 28092
- Black Decker Smart Select Jigsaw
- Tacklife Jigsaw
Proxxon 28092: the best coping saw?
The German brand Proxxon, a specialist in mini tools, offers the model maker, model maker, joiner and cabinetmaker the 28092 DSH 2 coping saw, a high-performance machine for cutting wood, metal or plastic. It features a 205-watt motor capable of delivering a maximum speed of 1500 blade strokes per minute. Stable, precise, solid and good finish, discover the many qualities that this Proxxon 28092 saw has.
The strong points
The engine: The Proxxon 28092 saw has a DSH brushless, two-speed motor capable of withstand intensive use. Although powerful, with 205 watts, the engine operates the blade at 900 or 1500 shots per minute. Adjusting the speed of the blade to one of these two values allows you to switch from a slow mode that focuses on accuracy to a fast mode that promotes efficiency.
Cutting capacity: Thanks to the double speed, you can work different materials like wood for a thickness not exceeding 5 cm, non-ferrous metal for a thickness not exceeding 1 cm, or plastic less than 3 cm. cm. Of course, you can also make materials such as fiberglass, plexiglass, rubber, foam, leather or cork. The management of the regime is done by an electronic variator.
Convenience: The Proxxon 28092 Scroll Saw is a quiet machine equipped with a cast steel base box so you can work without vibrations. Its 360 x 180 mm sawing table is made of high quality aluminum casting, which is very light, but particularly stable, to give you all the precision needed for fretwork. The saw arm has been designed to be slim so you have great visibility when cutting.
Solidity: One of the hallmarks of the German Proxxon label is the high quality and durability of its products. The scroll saw 28092 DSH 2 is no exception to the rule. Cast steel and cast aluminum are the main materials used to make this saw. The assembly is well cared for, as well as the finish. It is only a pity that there is no indication concerning the product warranty.
The weak spots
The blow gun: The 28092 Proxxon Scroll Saw is equipped with an adjustable blow gun to permanently clear your work surface. It is, however, a pity that it is not automated, but activated manually, which turns out to be complicated in practice. It would be more logical and practical for this function to be mechanically managed.
You can find this model right here: https://www.amazon.com/d/Sandpaper-Rolls/Proxxon-28092-Dsh-2-Spd-Scrollsaw240V/B0017V817A/ref=sr_1_fkmr0_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1543930257&sr=8-1-fkmr0&keywords=Proxxon+28092++jigsaws
BLACK+DECKER BDEJS600C Smart Select Jig Saw: the best quality/price ratio of the moment
This is a brand specializing in the manufacture of woodworking machines. Its range of products ranges from workshop tools to professional tools. Among its many saws, this can make fully 45-degree bevel cuts; with an adjustable shoe for stability. It is well suited to model makers, model makers, and any carpenter or cabinetmaker wishing to make curvilinear cuts of precision. Focus on the characteristic points of this jigsaw.
The quality/price ratio: The Black Decker Jigsaw perfectly meets the high quality. Its frame is made of high-quality materials that can last for a lifetime. And, it is one of the best-rated products when it comes to talk about quality/price ratio, according to the latest reviews. The quality is also reflected in the performance of the device, although it is a cheap entry-level model. The quality/price ratio of this scroll saw is therefore very advantageous.
Functionality and versatility: This saw can perform many additional operations besides fretwork. You can use it for cutting, engraving, drilling, polishing and grinding, thanks to a 3.2 mm diameter mandrel hose with which it is equipped. In particular, you can attach very small tools.
The comfort of use: Is equipped with a table of 255 x 415 mm, tilting up to 45 °. So you have plenty of space to work, but especially to master the room you sing. This worktop is always clean thanks to the 35 mm sawdust and chip suction mouth. The entire frame is stable and the engine perfectly discreet and sober to dispense unnecessary vibrations.
Electronic Speed Control: It’s features are electronically controlled, speed controller that allows you to adjust the cutting speed to the type of material you are working on. The saw is therefore ideal for model making using plastic, plexiglass, foam, leather, nonferrous metal, fiberglass apart from wood.
The guarantee: One of the strong points of this scroll saw is the 2-year warranty offered by the brand Scheppach. Of course, this warranty covers only normal use of the device. Anyway, the brand may grant you to return the product in case of failure, after you have sent them a contact form.
The weak spots
The brightness of the lamp: The Ssaw is equipped with a lamp mounted on a flexible arm. If the ignition is independent of the machine in terms of operation, however, we regret its lack of intensity that significantly affects the visibility of the room, but also the quality and safety of work.
Tack Life a cheap but reliable scroll saw
The selling price: For a cheap coping saw, you are in front of one of the most affordable of the market. Of course, is not intended for professional use, it is rather intended for personal use for all amateur models, model making, carpentry and cabinet making. It is a scroll saw very cheap, but it does a quality job and full of finesse.
Stability: The strength and stability of the frame hit the first glance at this saw. This stability guarantees the quality of your curved cuts. In particular, you can screw the appliance directly onto the workbench with the help of a convenient fixing system. You also have a presser to hold the parts you are working on the worktop.
The engine: For a cheap coping saw, it has a powerful motor. This power allows to drive the blade at a speed of 1600 strokes per minute, which is largely sufficient for all fretwork work and cutting on soft and semi-hard materials.
The variable speed drive: One of the strengths of this saw is its ability to vary its blade speed depending on the materials and work to be done. This electronically controlled power variator allows you to regulate the speed from 400 to 1600 revolutions per minute. In addition to providing user comfort, the ability of the device to vary its speed contributes to your safety.
Handling and cleanliness: With the Tack Life coping saw, it is easy to change blades because the machine has a quick clamping system. A blowing device allows you to keep the workpiece free from sawdust. A suction connection, on the other hand, helps you to remove dust and keep your workplace pleasantly clean.
The weak spots
The practical side: Firstly, the transparent plastic protection to protect you against sawdust and the blade becomes troublesome in practice especially from the point of view visibility of the workpiece. Then it would have been better if the speed control was done by pedal.
You can find this model right here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B074QJSNQY/ref=sspa_dk_detail_4?psc=1&pd_rd_i=B074QJSNQY&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_p=f0dedbe2-13c8-4136-a746-4398ed93cf0f&pd_rd_wg=prBze&pf_rd_r=31Z4G1KS4812XZ54RN6N&pf_rd_s=desktop-dp-sims&pf_rd_t=40701&pd_rd_w=cViMV&pf_rd_i=desktop-dp-sims&pd_rd_r=eca42e95-f7c9-11e8-af3e-e3e305b368bd
Band saw or scroll saw?
Many carpentry enthusiasts are reluctant to choose a scroll saw or band saw for fretwork. Indeed, the band saw is a versatile tool because it allows both cutting, cutting, edging and fretwork. What is the use of a coping saw? What are the advantages and disadvantages? Here are some answers that could enlighten you.
If on the outward appearance the electric jig saw holds a bit of a band saw, the operating mode of the two devices is quite different. A coping saw uses a straight blade held by a reciprocating swing arm, while the band saw uses a motor-driven closed-band blade through rotating flywheels.
The advantages and disadvantages
With a coping saw, you can work on closed parts by making a hole in the material and sliding the blade, which is not possible with a band saw. You can also make very tight and very precise curves with this type of saw, however, it sins on straight cuts.
A band saw, on the other hand, is more dexterous and faster for straight cuts. It also allows a good cutting height, which is rather limited to 50 mm for a coping saw. On the other hand, the bandsaw is more dangerous from the point of view of safety (inertia of the rotating elements) which is not the case for the saw with scrolling. In addition, the latter is more affordable in terms of maintenance (sharpening and replacement blades).
How to choose a scroll saw?
The scroll saw is the tool par excellence for curvilinear cutting. In fact, the term singing comes from the combination of the words singing and turning. If the first designates the side of a panel, usually wood or other material, the second shows the action that makes this side of the panel curved. Thus the fretwork serves a lot in marquetry, model making, cabinet making and carpentry in general. If you want to buy one, here are the things to watch out for.
The type of scroll saw
There are two types of coping saws. The first, the manual coping saw, is operated by a handle attached to a U-shaped structure. Lighter and more compact, it is however less used today.
A version called “bocfil” is used especially for jewelers, luthiers, marquetry and furniture restorers. The second, the electric coping saw, has a small motor to move the blade back and forth. It has the advantage of being fast, comfortable to use and well equipped.
The depth of the gooseneck
This data, which varies between 30 and 60 cm for the electric jig saw and between 8 and 30 cm for the manual jig saw, makes it possible to evaluate the maximum height of the workpiece that you can work. In other words, the higher the value, the more you can sing a large room.
The power of the engine
This feature is unique to the electric scroll saw. Generally, the power of a saw motor is between 70 and 200 watts, and feeds via a conventional 230 V single-phase connection. Indeed, this kind of saw does not need a very powerful motor. Its sobriety and balance are a real plus if you want to work with precision and meticulousness. So prefer asynchronous motors, because they are more robust, quieter and vibrate less compared to conventional coal engines.
The speed of the saw
Speed matters because the faster you have a blade, the more you can work hard materials. It is therefore chosen according to the material you sing and is often between 900 and 1400 beats per minute. However, it should be noted that the presence of a variable speed drive is a great asset, since it reduces blade strokes in sensitive areas and acute angles. A slower speed allows you to press the precision, while the opposite allows you a fast advancement.
The work plan
The fretwork table also delimits your working comfort and your precision in the fretwork. It must be assumed that the larger the table, the more you will be able to master the room you are singing. In addition to its size, remember that it must be strong and slippery. The presence of a presser can be a great help in keeping the workpiece against the table, while a miter guide allows you to cut very precisely.
In addition to the drive controller already mentioned above, the ergonomics of the scroll saw can be improved by the existence of small options such as the presence of adapters for mounting the different blades (pins or slats), lamp for more visual comfort, magnifying glass to improve accuracy, but especially pedal control so you can master your cut.
A suction outlet or a blower can also be a great asset in the sense that your work plan will stay clean as you move through the fretwork.
Maintenance and handling
A good coping saw must have a quick blade disassembly system and a fast blade tensioning system. Indeed, it can happen that a project requires a frequent change of blade. It is even better if the saw is compatible with a blade without pins that allows especially to sing very fine patterns.
This is an important point in the choice of a scroll saw since the price ranges between $40 and $2000. Obviously, a very low price will be at the expense of the quality of the material and the precision of its work. You do not have to aim for the very high end if you only need to use the saw occasionally.